In his new book Technology panic: why we should not be afraid of Facebook and the future, Robby Soave questioned the traditional view that social media poses an unprecedented threat to the well-being of American youth.
“I think people’s panic on social media is out of proportion to the actual harm,” Soave said in episode 488. Geek Galaxy Guide podcast. “Many are exaggerated; many are exaggerated.”
He said the current anger on social media is reminiscent of the way politicians talk about video games, such as doom with Mortal Kombat Back in the 90s. “All the claims about video games 20 years ago turned out to be untrue-they did not promote violence and did not turn young people into school shooters,” he said. “I wonder if we will look back at this moral panic in a similar way in 10 or 20 years.”
Many contributions have been made to the power of the algorithms developed by Facebook and Google, which Soave said is reminiscent of the earlier panic about the dangers of subliminal advertising. “When I’m on Facebook, I like this, I get [ads for] Dungeons and Dragons Commodities instead of car advertisements,” he said. “If I watch TV, I will see car advertisements. I am not going to buy a car. not my business. I wish I could fast forward through them. On Facebook, I saw things I might really like. This is a good thing. “
Technology companies are under fire from the entire political arena, from Donald Trump and Senator Josh Holly to President Biden and Senator Elizabeth Warren, everyone is calling for new regulations. Soaf said it would be a huge mistake to allow politicians to exert too much power on one of America’s most innovative industries. “Perhaps for a lot of people, they will say,’Well, if everyone in the government wants this, it means it’s right,’ and I’m the opposite-if everyone wants this , That must be bad,” he said.
Listen to the full interview with Robby Soave in episode 488 Geek Galaxy Guide (above). And check out some of the highlights in the discussion below.
Robbie Soff Dungeons and Dragons:
“I am now at [dungeon mastering] Two groups, I played in the third group, although that is over, I think they will take my character to a different group. So there is a lot of overlap between my different worlds and roles.So interesting…because I did it for Liberal Magazine, My main team is very free in game style. The other group is a little more to the right. The main difference I noticed is that the groups further to the right do like to fight and kill everything they encounter and kill the characters I come up with, while the liberals want to talk about their own way or exchange things. They will avoid fighting at all costs. “
Robby Soave on cancellation culture:
“I have written a lot of cases about what people call’cancel culture’. People have been attacked or criticized for writing something or doing something that may be insensitive or offensive to some extent, but they did not kill. It shouldn’t be the end of their lives… This is strange, especially for those progressive leftists who often believe in criminal justice reform. This is what I support-people who were previously imprisoned should The idea of being able to live a normal life, and that they should be able to find a job again, and you don’t have to ask about their imprisonment status-this is forgivable. I totally agree, but someone said something might be racist at the age of 15 If you find this tweet, they shouldn’t be hired anymore? It’s meaningless to me.”
Robby Soave in the media:
“The villain in my book is actually the mainstream media and New York Times Especially… you can travel through time and space. With every invention, especially in the field of communications, you will find that they panic about it… But from an industry perspective, it makes sense. Because many of these technologies are New York Times, Was rated as a competitor by the newspaper. “
Robby Soave of Silicon Valley:
“Silicon Valley’s culture has become somewhat hostile to innovation, it keeps people away [California]My point of making this point is, let us not repeat this point across the country. The anti-tech rhetoric from everyone in Congress is so comprehensive. They now treat social media like big tobacco companies — we hear it over and over again. But Big Tobacco has killed millions of people, and even the most serious accusation against Instagram, no one thinks it killed hundreds of people. So this is a ridiculous comparison. This kind of subconscious anti-technology sentiment from policy makers and legislators is not good for our country, bad for society, and bad for innovation. “